On October 23-26, 2016, USF’s Dr. Joseph Moxley, Director of Composition, and Dr. Jhon Figueroa, Chemistry Instructor presented at the Southeastern Regional Meeting of the American Chemical Society (SERMACS). Dr. Moxley and Dr. Figueroa used MyReviewers to observe peer review habits in 2373 Chemistry students. Their findings suggest that students are able to recognize A, B, and C-level lab reports when completing peer review. Student comments on lab reports became more helpful as they completed more peer reviews. This new direction in peer feedback represents the real-world writing and critical thinking skills that USF Chemistry students learn throughout the semester.